The backfire effect is a cognitive bias that refers to the tendency for people to reject evidence that contradicts their existing beliefs. This can happen even when the evidence is presented clearly and convincingly.
The backfire effect is thought to be caused by several factors, including the following:
- Confirmation bias: This is the tendency to seek out and interpret information that confirms our existing beliefs.
- Ego threat: When presented with evidence contradicting our beliefs, it can threaten our sense of self. This can lead us to reject the proof to protect our ego. For example, if you allow your colleagues to do the heavy lifting for you and you're freewheeling on their revenue generation, you will feel bad when they say you're not pulling your weight. Perhaps you have lost interest in the business or prefer to take your daughter to dancing lessons twice a week when you could be working late. Some people don't enjoy taking instructions from people/leaders/managers they have no respect for, preferring to stick with the status quo bias. Some people will resist change simply because they're comfortable with what they have. Railing against change can have negative consequences; the worst is the thought that perhaps you've let yourself and your family down.
- Need for closure: We often strongly need to feel sure about our beliefs. This can make us resistant to new information that challenges our assumptions.
The backfire effect can have many negative consequences. It can make it difficult to have productive conversations about important issues. It can also make it challenging to learn from our mistakes.
We can do a few things to try to avoid the backfire effect. These include:
- Awareness of the bias: The first step is to be aware of the backfire effect. Once we are aware of it, we can start to look for ways to overcome it.
- Presenting the evidence in a non-threatening way: When we present evidence to someone who holds a different belief, it is essential to do so in a way that is not threatening. This means avoiding language that is accusatory or condescending.
- Focusing on the process: Instead of focusing on the conversation's outcome, it is more helpful to focus on the process. This means being open to hearing different perspectives and being willing to change your mind if the evidence warrants it.
The backfire effect is complex, and there is no easy way to overcome it. However, by being aware of the bias and avoiding it, we can make it less likely.
There are many Cognitive Biases, many more than most people realise. If you want to think your way out of a mind trap, you must first realise that you're already trapped.
If you want to enhance your professional skill set or help an employee on the road to success, enrol on our 5-Day Discovery Public Speaking Course. The course helps you to polish your skills so you can present comfortably to the board and other industry professionals. Book a place on this 5-day course for just £1750 + VAT. It's a life-changing event.
